Wednesday, July 16, 2008

white quotation of the week (andrea gibson)



See Through

We're on our way back to school from gymnastics class.
And only in Boulder, Colorado,
the kids are singing John Lennon's "Imagine"
at the back of the bus, when

Jesse stops herself mid-verse,
stretches her arm across the aisle like a sunbeam,
tugs at the edge of my shirt and asks,
"What does hatred mean?"

Jesse's five years old.
Anything I say, she's gonna believe.
But I realize, I don't know the answer.
I'm not sure what hatred means.
I could guess and say it's the opposite of love.
I could guess and say,
"Jesse, hatred is why there are nothing but white faces
on our private-school bus."

But Jesse isn't white yet.
Go ahead and ask her.

"What color are you, Jesse?"

"Well, it looks like I'm pink."

Shane thinks he's orange.
Skylar says she's tan.
Rhett says he's see-through.
"See, you can see how my veins are blue
but they're red when I bleed."

And I wish there was no such thing as springtime.
'Cause I don't trust the machines
that will one day be planting seeds in these gardens
teaching them that some people are flowers
some people are weeds,
rip the weeds by their roots
ignore their screams
tilt your own face to the sun
take what you want,
you are the chosen ones.

Sitting Bull said white people are liars and thieves.
I wanna tell Jesse he was wrong.

I wanna tell her we didn't come like a time bomb,
gunpowder on our breath,
teeth built like bullets,
that this land didn't weep when our feet
first mercilessly hit the ground.
I don't want to say we drowned and maimed the children,
sliced long strips of their skin for bridle reins,
I don't wanna say the moon was slain,
the constellations dispersed like shrapnel.
Mothers killed their babies, then killed themselves
when they saw our faces on the horizon
and all that we left was a trail of tears.

But if I have to say that,
I wanna say our boats stopped there.
I wanna say the waves never saw the sails of slave ships,
never heard the sound of chain links,
but Jesse, think slaughterhouse.
Think people branded, suffocating, foaming at the mouth.
Can you imagine what kind of pain you would have to endure,
to throw yourself overboard 2000 miles out to sea?
Lungs gratefully exchanging breath for saltwater,
gratefully trading life for death.

Can you imagine being chained to your dead daughter?
How many days would it take you to stop
searching her hands for lifelines?
To stop searching her fingertips for remnants of sunshine?
To stop searching her wrists for a pulse,
for just some sign of time turning backwards
to when you knew
people could never do things like this?

And Jesse this
is not just a picture of our history,
not just a picture of our past.
We've been hundreds of years
measuring the size of our hearts
by the size of our fists,
erecting our bliss on the broken backs of dark skin.
The present is far from gift-wrapped.

Ask New Orleans,
Ask mothers in the Bronx,
chasing rats out of their babies' cribs.
Ask the fathers of the kids
whose lives we exchange for cheap gas.
Ask our prisons why jail bars always come in black.
Ask Afghanistan, Palestine, Iraq.
Ask the woman in Thailand whose cancer builds our laptops.
Ask the Mexican man working in a field fertilized
by nerve gas.
Ask his daughter when she's born without fingers
or hands to pray with.
Ask me how long I could keep going with this list.
God might be watching,
but we are not.

You are white, Jesse.
There are bodies dangling
from the limbs of your family tree.
Our people pull people from the soil like weeds.
Breathe in our story.
Force yourself to hold in your lungs
'til you can hear our hymns sung beneath white sheets.
'til your can feel your own finger on the trigger of the gun.
Feel yourself fire as they shout.
Do not look away as bullet enters heartbeat.
Now breathe out.
This is where we come from.
This is still where we are.
Now where will we go from here?

I don't believe we're hateful.
I think mostly we're just asleep.
But the math adds up the same.
You can't call up the dead and say,
"Sorry, we were looking the other way."

There are names and faces behind our apathy,
eulogies beneath our choices.
There are voices deep as roots
thundering unquestionable truth
through the white noise that pacifies our ears.
Don't tell me we don't hear.
Don't tell me we don't hear.
When the moon is slain,
when the constellations disperse like shrapnel,
don't you think it's time,
something changed?


Andrea Gibson is "a queer poet/activist whose work deconstructs the foundations of the current political machine, highlighting issues such as patriarchy, gender norms, white supremacy, and capitalist culture." A performance poet who has won multiple slam contests, headlined at major venues, and appeared on Free Speech TV, Dyke TV, the BBC, and in the film Slam Planet, Gibson has also self-released three CDs and three books.

Transcribed from an audio file available here, the above poem also appears in Gibson's first published book, Pole Dancing to Gospel Hymns. Performances of many of her poems are available on YouTube.

Tuesday, July 15, 2008

ask for suggestions



White reader Liza sent me the following email, asking for suggestions about how to get a dialogue on race started in her small, predominantly white town.

I've offered some suggestions below; do you have others for her? What can an ordinary person do to promote discussions of whiteness, and of race more generally, in her own community?


Hello,

Just found this blog yesterday and am intrigued. I am a white woman in my early 40's who lives in a predominantly white rural town of about 4000 people. I have always tried my best to instill in my children non-racist views, but with only a couple of black kids at our school, I have found few opportunities to really broach the subject in a way that doesn't sound like an after school special.

I know that there is racism in the world, in our community, and I would like them to be more prepared to deal with these things as they head out into the world, not to mention working on my own understanding. I have thought of trying to start a social group or study group of some kind to get a dialogue going, but I fear making a novelty out of the blacks in our town if I suggest such a thing.

Are there any suggestions out there?

Thanks, Liza



Hello Liza,

First of all, I applaud your efforts. America is moving toward the probability of electing its first black* president, yet the ongoing effects and manifestations of American white supremacy continue to cause declining circumstances and fortunes for many non-white people. Serious, productive local dialogues on race are as crucial as ever, and yet, such a conversation is rarely welcome in a residential setting like yours.

It's interesting that your desire to address race is framed in terms of the few black folks in your town. Have you considered addressing instead, somehow, the majority? White folks have a race too, even though in a setting like yours, they probably rarely ever think seriously about what it means to be "white" (and when they do, they tend to think and talk about it in objectionable ways, as I'm sure you know).

Starting a social or reading group on "race" is a great idea. Churches often have the space (and sometimes, some resources) for such a gathering, as do libraries and town halls. Even a restaurant or a coffee shop can be a good meeting place, and moving an established group from home to home can also work well.

A reading group could focus on race in many ways. There are innumerable novels and memoirs that address race, including whiteness (which again, I recommend as your focus, since your group members are likely to be mostly or all white). If you'd eventually like some reading suggestions, write back to me--I have a long list. You could also consider the ones I've reviewed so far on this blog.

Watching films together and then discussing them afterward is also a good way to get a dialogue going. Race and whiteness are depicted in ways that can be discussed in just about any movie, though some are more likely to generate discussion than others. One that has proven its value for this purpose in, I'm sure, thousands of such gatherings is The Color of Fear, a powerful documentary about a multiracial group of men who discuss their racial experiences together.

These sorts of documentaries are often accompanied by discussion guides (as are many novels and memoirs that deal with race). As I noted in yesterday's post, you could begin working with films by asking your local library to purchase them. For instance, Free Indeed is a brief, inexpensive drama about white privilege and service work, put together by the Mennonite Central Committee.

If you can generate enough interest on this topic in your community to get some funds together, you might consider inviting a speaker on whiteness and racial issues. Again, the local library can be a good setting for this. If you're familiar with Tim Wise, for instance, he's not as expensive as you might think. Many scholars from colleges in your state would also be willing to speak for a modest fee on particular aspects of the topic (and Google can help you find them). "Whiteness" has been a topic of intensive interest and study for at least a decade now, and as a result, many speakers are available for such talks.

Particular lecture and discussion-group topics could include race relations in your particular part of the state or country--how, for instance, did it get so white? (It wasn't an accident, nor the mere coincidence that most of your town's current residents probably think it was). Was your town a "sundown town"? (James Loewen is also a traveling speaker, and a damn good one too.) Who were the particular indigenous groups that inhabited your area, and what happened to them? How did the European immigrants to your area become "white," and why did they do so? How does their choice to become "white" continue to affect the lives of their descendants today? How is race addressed in your local schools? What are the area's kids learning about race, and how else are they learning it? How is race played out in your community in relation to other factors, such as social class, or gender, or the larger national and even international economies? Are there, for instance, migrant workers in your area? If so, how long has that been happening, and why did it start? What do local white people think, and perhaps fail to understand, about migrant workers?

Finally, I do not suggest a sort of celebratory, appreciative, buffet-like approach to these matters. White supremacy isn't just a thing of the past, but too many white efforts to address "race" end up merely celebrating other races (and often in limited, simplistic, and patronizing ways), instead of addressing "whiteness" and its significance for ongoing inequities and injustices.

I hope that this blog's readers will add other suggestions for you in this post's "comments" section, and I wish you the best of luck in this important effort. You'll probably meet some resistance, and you'll need to be persistent and brave if you really do want to get people thinking and acting. But that's the only way that the kind of change you're looking for ever happens.

Best of luck, and please let me know sometime what becomes of your efforts,

macon d


*This word originally appeared as "black" (with quotation marks around it), but in response to a discussion about that in the Comments section for this post, I've removed the quotation marks. Thanks to jw, Lori, and Restructure! for addressing this issue.

Monday, July 14, 2008

ask their local libraries to buy movies

Today's post is a movie recommendation, and a clip from that movie: Shakti Butler's Mirrors of Privilege: Making Whiteness Visible. Normal superlatives for good movies apply -- inspiring, thought-provoking, powerful, moving, insightful, and many more.

You can order a copy here. It's a bit expensive, so if you can't afford it, why not ask a nearby librarian to order a copy instead? You'd be helping out a very worthy organization, World Trust Educational Services, and you'd also be planting a seed in your local library that could flourish into further awareness of white privilege and the ways of white folks.

(Below the clip is a brief review of the film by Carol Estes.)






Review of Mirrors of Privilege:

“I wake up every single morning of my life and think, ‘I am a black person,’” says a professor in the film Mirrors of Privilege: Making Whiteness Visible.
It’s different for me. I’m white, but not once did I ever wake up and think, “I am a white person.” In my mirror, I don’t see a white person, just a person, and I might even congratulate myself on that.
But it’s nothing to be proud of, according to this film. It means I’m colorblind in a particularly problematic way: I can’t see whiteness. I can avoid acknowledging the racial privileges that have supported my successes and sustain the comfortable myth that I earned my perch near the top of the social ladder.
Mirrors of Privilege, a simply made but surprisingly compelling film, introduces white people to the part of our whiteness we’ve learned not to see, through a series of conversations with white people who have thought deeply about race. A professor of women’s studies from New York recalls feeling baffled after reading two essays from African American women arguing that white women were oppressive to work for. “How can that be?” she wondered. “We’re so nice.” She decided to investigate. “If I have anything I didn’t earn,” she told herself, “show me.” She meditated over this challenge and within three months had identified 46 examples.
Throughout the film, some scenarios are powerfully illustrated in dance. One tableau shows three people, down on all fours, lined up shoulder to shoulder. Across their backs reclines a white woman, languorously reading a book, oblivious to the trembling arms of the black man who’s holding her up.
These are images and voices that have been largely missing from America’s discussion of race—articulate, principled, caring white people struggling to come to grips with their own fear, guilt, and ambivalence. They form, as anti-racism activist Van Jones puts it, “a cry from the heart of white people working to restore their own humanity.”



Carol Estes wrote this review as part of A Just Foreign Policy, the Summer 2008 issue of YES! Magazine. Carol Estes is a YES! contributing editor, and for eight years has sponsored the Black Prisoners Caucus at a men’s prison in Monroe, Washington, where she co-founded the program University Behind

Sunday, July 13, 2008

refuse to bury their dead in black cemeteries

A handmade grave-marker at
the Lamington Black Cemetery
in Bedminster, New Jersey


Most white Americans think that racial segregation died with the end of the "Jim Crow" era. However, in many areas of life, white people continue to separate themselves from non-white people--even when life is over.

Americans in general don't spend much time pondering death. The awareness of our own impending mortality--an awareness that perhaps most truly separates us from other animals--is continually repressed for us by America's consumerist, live-for-the-moment society.

In fact, in many ways, Americans more or less deny death, including the mass deaths caused in so many places by our white supremacist foreign policies.

As for white Americans, I think it's safe to assume that most of them probably aren't even aware of the many black cemeteries out there. If so, it means that they haven't taken another step in this regard, which is to consider what it would mean to be buried in such a place. To be a white corpse in the ground, surrounded by black corpses. To have those friends and relatives who are willing to visit their white remains come less often, because this cemetery is known as a "black cemetery."

And why, you might ask, would the possibility of a white body's burial in a black cemetery ever come up in the first place?

Here's a recent story about an incident in Texas where this possibility did arise. In this case, members of the white community rallied around a white body that was in danger of ending up in a black cemetery, apparently in an effort to "save" it from such an ignominious state of final rest. After all, the logic here seems to go, how could a white person ever rest in peace if she's surrounded by black people?


Racial divide stirred by burial of murder victim

By MONICA RHOR Associated Press Writer
© 2008 The Associated Press

HOUSTON — More than a year ago, an unidentified woman's body was found on a road, her dark hair shorn off, a plastic bag taped around her head, her hands severed. She had been strangled and tossed away by her killer.

Today, the crime remains unsolved, the murder victim's name is still unknown and efforts to bury her have set off controversy in Waller County — a rural area just west of Houston that has long been roiled by racial divisions.

The victim is white, while the funeral home and cemetery that a justice of the peace initially chose to handle her burial in Hempstead are historically black.

But Waller County Commissioners Court balked at paying for that burial. When activists started raising questions about the county's hesitation at burying the woman in a black cemetery, the commissioners asked a white-owned funeral home in Waller to handle arrangements.

That outraged Walter Pendleton, a local black minister who filed a federal lawsuit against the city of Hempstead that forced it to integrate its public cemeteries.

"I'm just appalled right now. I can't believe this county stooped that low," he said. "The county overstepped its boundary to get a white funeral home to pick up the body so that it could not be buried in a black cemetery."

The victim would be the first known white person buried in a black cemetery in Waller County. Since March 25, Waller County has paid neighboring Harris County $50 a day to store the body.

"I have never seen such defiance and determination to protect a segregated system," said DeWayne Charleston, the Waller County justice of the peace who first ordered the black funeral home to handle the arrangements.

Judge Owen Ralston, the county's top elected official, denied that racial issues were at play. "I didn't know if the victim was black or white, and I didn't care," Ralston said.

Rather, he attributed the delay in burial to the black funeral home director's insistence that the county sign a letter guaranteeing payment. Ralston said that went against county policy, and instead contacted another funeral home to handle the arrangements.

The white-owned funeral home picked up the woman's body on Monday — the same day community activists sent out a news release calling attention to the situation.

That a nameless murder victim's burial is stirring claims of racial discrimination is not surprising in Waller County.

In 2006, the Texas Attorney General investigated claims that the rights of black voters were violated. Earlier this year, students at historically black Prairie View A&M University protested to bring attention to racially motivated voting problems in Waller County.

"The issue of racism always raises its head here — from voting rights to education, to the criminal justice system," Charleston said. "Waller County is stuck in the 19th century."

Charleston said he wasn't trying to cause trouble when he ordered the black funeral home to handle arrangements for the woman. He was simply struck by the brutality of the crime and the poignancy of a murder victim with no family to claim her.

"You never know what her circumstances were. She could be from Texas and estranged from her family. She could be the victim of human trafficking," Charleston said. "She's certainly entitled to a dignified burial no matter what the circumstances. I'm treating her as though she is a kin of mine."

The woman's nude and mutilated body was found on a Prairie View road just before dawn on March 18, 2007. She is believed to be between 30 and 50 years old, and was likely killed at another location, then dumped on the roadside, police say.

"It was gruesome and that no one identified her or claimed her makes it more horrific," Charleston said. "I thought that this woman, if nothing else, was going to have the distinction of integrating Waller County cemeteries."


[The New York Times also covered this story]


PS--I have no idea how this poor woman came to her end, but her story reminds me of one of the most powerful films I've ever seen, Agnes Varda's Sans Toit ni Loi (Vagabond or Without Roof or Rule in English). Released in 1985, it follows a lone woman for awhile, raising questions (for me at least) about just what "freedom" and "community" really mean, especially when you die.

Here's a taste of it:

Saturday, July 12, 2008

white weekend links

  • "Study: Medical Students Show Racial Bias" ("content creator" Jessie Coleman @ CNN.com, via The Independent Florida Alligator)

    For each of the 21 medical students who enter the room, Edna's fears are still to be discovered. They each see the same 55-year-old woman, each meet with the same brown eyes. They all hear the same Southern twang in her voice and the same tremor of fear when she asks if she could have cancer. The only difference is that 12 of the students see a dark-skinned version of Edna, and the other nine students see a light-skinned version.

    Edna is a computer-animated image projected life-size on the side of a white wall, and she is used in a study monitoring the interactions of medical students with virtual patients. The study, which has three of five authors from [the University of Florida], found white medical students were less empathetic toward black virtual patients in one-on-one interviews.


  • "On Being Jewish and White" (The Girl Detective @ Feministe)

    I’ve written before on how angry I was when fellow progressives began to inform me that while some Jews consider themselves white, it’s only because they’ve assimilated into white culture. They never explained what white-looking Jews actually are, if not white, but the message was always clear: if we Ashkenazi (Eastern European) Jews think we’re white, well, it’s just because we wanted some of that tasty privilege so badly that we suppressed our real identity to get it. I’d known, of course, that many white extremists still considered Jewishness a race, but hearing such comments come from leftists surprised and upset me for a couple of reasons: 1) they were presuming to know more about a Jew’s identity than a Jew would, and 2) those who were people of color were surely familiar with the frustration at having others dictate how they should define themselves.


  • "The White Stuff: What Does an Extremely Popular New Blog about White Culture Tell Us About Race in America?" (Samhita Mukhopadhyay @ The American Prospect)

    Lander didn't set out to write an academic treatise on whiteness. Rather, he set out to joke about it. What sets it apart from the hundreds of other well-written, funny Web sites is that it's hit a nerve--especially because it appeared at a time when America was captivated by the issue of race in the presidential primary. And so it's worth thinking about exactly what this blog tells us about whiteness and why its mostly white, affluent audience has so enthusiastically embraced this gently mocking rundown of their culture. . . . Stuff White People Like is a "safe" place for white people to talk about race . . .


  • "Is 'White Privilege' Real?" (Michelle DiMartino @ "Exploring Race," a forum at the Chicago Tribune Web Edition)

    During my job search, I noticed that when I would go to a job bank, I was treated differently in comparison to minorities. The agents grilled me, not to help me get a job, but to find out why I didn’t have one. They wanted to know what I had done to make myself so poor. They also asked why I didn’t have a family member who could help me. Did they ask this just because I’m white? As someone holding a philosophy degree I cannot help but be, well, philosophical. Without a college degree you can’t earn a living wage, and without paying for college you cannot get a degree. If your parents don’t make a lot of money or if you don’t earn scholarships, then you will have to take out many student loans. When you leave school and can’t find a job, you can find yourself back where you started. Being any particular race doesn’t help you at all when you belong to the lowest socioeconomic class and you’re struggling to pull yourself up. I am white but throughout my life I have not known white privilege. Not in the least.


  • "I'm Not Racist, I Have Black Friends" (Renee @ Womanist Musings)

    How much longer do white people believe they can use the I have a "black friend" card to cover their clearly racist behaviour? . . . I think I have finally figured out the mystery of the black friend...he/she is imaginary aren't they? ...Yep, your "pretend buddy" that you can whip out every time the word racist is thrown your way. Here is a little tip, next time you go to pull the "black friend" out of your defence arsenal, please be aware that this excuse has worn thin, and we (anti-racists) are on to your sorry, lying asses.


  • "A White Man Does the Right Thing: The Courage to Stand against Racism" (Joe Feagin @ Racism Review)

    L. F. Eason III, a white North Carolina state manager with a distinguished record of state employment . . . was forced to retire (in reality, fired) because he would not allow the employees at his laboratory to lower the flag to honor one of the most infamous of the white-racist advocates ever to serve in the U.S. Senate, the unrepentant anti-civil-rights advocate, Senator Jesse Helms.



And finally, a video that may well suggest--contrary to what I've been periodically saying on this blog--that perhaps white people should NOT dance more often than they do.



Friday, July 11, 2008

use racially coded jungle settings to promote the consumption of another animal's baby food

The white race cannot survive without dairy products.

--Herbert Hoover


In continuation of this blog's ongoing examination of "white world-traveling," I submit here another item for consideration and discussion. Look at all the "whiteness" in this video, and at all the non-whiteness used as a backdrop for it. Is this racist? Species-ist? Milk-ist?


Watch. Listen. Drink from the milky white river. Ponder. Discuss.





[hat-tip to Alterdestiny for the Hoover quote]

Thursday, July 10, 2008

overlook the racism of the justice system


[This is a guest post from SWPD reader jw, who adds the following self-description: "As a white German I see it as my responsibility that history never again can repeat itself. Without ideology I am politically left, embracing humanism and trying to be a part in the fight against the system of white supremacy. Anti-racism is more than just being against racism." jw also wrote recently about how white people "sacrifice the selves of their children"]






The reality is that capital punishment in America is a lottery. It is a punishment that is shaped by the constraints of poverty, race, geography and local politics.

--Bryan Stevenson, Death Row lawyer


While it may seem that America is "tough on crime," the prison industry, along with the police and the judiciary, plays an important role of control and the demonstration of power.

The United States has the highest incarceration rate in the world , at 737 persons imprisoned per 100,000. A report released Feb. 28, 2008 indicates that in the United States more than 1 in 100 adults is now confined in an American jail or prison. The United States has 5% of the world's population and 25% of the world's incarcerated population.

According to the Bureau of Justice, Blacks are almost three times more likely than Hispanics and five times more likely than whites to be in jail.

And while white supremacists use such statistics to "prove" their argument that Black people are more prone to crime than white folks, the real reasons for such high incarceration rates are racial profiling and the so-called "War on Drugs."

Human Rights Watch writes that

African-Americans are arrested, prosecuted, and imprisoned for drug offenses at far higher rates than whites. This racial disparity bears little relationship to racial differences in drug offending. For example, although the proportion of all drug users who are black is generally in the range of 13 to 15 percent, blacks constitute 36 percent of arrests for drug possession. Blacks constitute 63 percent of all drug offenders admitted to state prisons. In at least fifteen states, black men were sent to prison on drug charges at rates ranging from twenty to fifty-seven times those of white men.

After slavery, slave patrollers, the KKK and Jim Crow, white control over Black people took on a new dimension, which is not "tough on crime" but tough on non-white people (and also poor white people).

Thus it is no surprise that the USA still practices the death penalty as another way of demonstrating its utmost power. America is a nation that still believes it should decide who has the right to live and who does not. However, the right to live is a Human Right, and the application of the death penalty is violating a basic human right in the name of "justice."

One argument for the death penalty is that it deters homicide. But as a New York Times study discovered, statistics do not demonstrate the efficiency of the death penalty.

The dozen states that have chosen not to enact the death penalty since the Supreme Court ruled in 1976 that it was constitutionally permissible have not had higher homicide rates than states with the death penalty, government statistics and a new survey by The New York Times show.

Indeed, 10 of the 12 states without capital punishment have homicide rates below the national average, Federal Bureau of Investigation data shows, while half the states with the death penalty have homicide rates above the national average. In a state-by-state analysis, The Times found that during the last 20 years, the homicide rate in states with the death penalty has been 48 percent to 101 percent higher than in states without the death penalty.

The study by The Times also found that homicide rates had risen and fallen along roughly symmetrical paths in the states with and without the death penalty, suggesting to many experts that the threat of the death penalty rarely deters criminals.

The death penalty is also not actually used against the most brutal murderers. Instead, according to findings of Amnesty International,

a defendant was several times more likely to be sentenced to death if the murder victim was white. This confirms the findings of many other studies that, holding all other factors constant, the single most reliable predictor of whether someone will be sentenced to death is the race of the victim.

Underlying the statistical evidence is the differential treatment of African-Americans at every turn in the criminal justice system. From initial charging decisions to plea bargaining to jury sentencing, African-Americans are treated more harshly when they are defendants, and their lives are accorded less value when they are victims. Furthermore, all-white or virtually all-white juries are still commonplace in many localities.

That the justice system of America is seriously flawed is also proven by the many exonerations. "Since 1973, 129 people in 26 states have been released from death row with evidence of their innocence." (deathpenaltyinfo.org)

Also, Troy Davis was sentenced to death 1991 without proof of his guilt. There is no physical evidence against him and his conviction is based on witness testimony. His execution was halted, but "on Monday, March 17, 2008, the Georgia Supreme Court decided 4-3 to deny a new trial for Troy Anthony Davis, despite significant concerns regarding his innocence. Today's stunning decision by the Georgia Supreme Court to let Mr. Davis' death sentence stand means that the state of Georgia might soon execute a man who may well be innocent." (amnestyusa.org)

A criminal justice system where race becomes an influential factor is no system of justice. And a society that acts as a silent bystander, sides with the injustice. This is how white supremacy works--as a system in which the powerful decide who has a right to freedom and to life itself, and who does not.

Wednesday, July 9, 2008

white quotation of the week (karen brodkin)

Pictorial Report #43: "The G. I. Bill of Rights"
Army-Navy Screen Magazine




Regarding the racial significance of this bill, Karen Brodkin writes:


I continue to be surprised when I read books that indicate that America once regarded its immigrant European workers as something other than white, as biologically different. My parents are not surprised; they expect anti-Semitism to be part of the fabric of daily life, much as I expect racism to be part of it. They came of age in the Jewish world of the 1920s and 1930s, at the peak of anti-Semitism in America. They are rightly proud of their upward mobility and think of themselves as pulling themselves up by their own bootstraps. . . .

Part of my ethnic heritage was the belief that Jews were smart and that our success was due to our own efforts and abilities, reinforced by a culture that valued sticking together, hard work, education, and delayed gratification.

I am willing to affirm all those abilities and ideals and their contribution to Jews’ upward mobility, but I also argue that they were still far from sufficient to account for Jewish success. I say this because the belief in a Jewish version of Horatio Alger has become a point of entry for some mainstream Jewish organizations to adopt a racist attitude against African Americans especially and to oppose affirmative action for people of color. Instead, I want to suggest that Jewish success is a product not only of ability but also of the removal of powerful social barriers to its realization. . . .

[Suddenly, after World War II,] the same folks who had promoted nativism and xenophobia were eager to believe that the Euro-origin people whom they had deported, reviled as members of inferior races, and prevented from immigrating only a few years earlier, were now model middle-class white suburban citizens.

It was not an educational epiphany that made those in power change their hearts, their minds, and our race. Instead, it was the biggest and best affirmative action program in the history of our nation, and it was for Euromales. This is not how it was billed, but it is the way it worked out in practice. I tell this story to show the institutional nature of racism and the centrality of state policies to creating and changing races. Here, those policies reconfigured the category of whiteness to include European immigrants. . . .

The GI Bill of Rights, or the Serviceman’s Readjustment Act, is arguably the most massive affirmative action program in American history. It was created to develop needed labor force skills and to provide those who had them with a lifestyle that reflected their value in the economy. The GI benefits that were ultimately extended to 16 million GIs (of the Korean War as well) included priority in jobs—that is, preferential treatment, but no one objected to it then—financial support during the job search, small loans for starting up businesses, and most important, low-interest home loans and educational benefits, which included tuition and living expenses. This legislation was rightly regarded as one of the most revolutionary postwar programs. I call it affirmative action because it was aimed at and disproportionately helped male, Euro-origin GIs. . . .

The reason I refer to educational and occupational GI benefits as affirmative action programs for white males is because they were decidedly not extended to African Americans nor to women of any race. Theoretically they were available to all veterans; in practice women and black veterans did not get anywhere near their share. . . .

During and after the war, there was an upsurge in white racist violence against black servicemen, in public schools, and by the Ku Klux Klan. It spread to California and New York. The number of lynchings rose during the war, and in 1943 there were anti-black riots in several large northern cities. Although there was a wartime labor shortage, black people were discriminated against when it came to well-paid defense industry jobs and housing. In 1946, white riots against African Americans occurred across the South and in Chicago and Philadelphia.

Gains made as a result of the wartime civil rights movement, especially in defense-related employment, were lost with peacetime conversion, as black workers were the first to be fired, often in violation of seniority. White women were also laid off, ostensibly to make room for jobs for demobilized servicemen, and in the long run women lost most of the gains they had made in wartime. . . .

Black GIs faced discrimination in the educational system as well. Despite the end of restrictions on Jews and other Euro-ethnics, African Americans were not welcome in white colleges. Black colleges were overcrowded, but the combination of segregation and prejudice made for few alternatives. About 20,000 black veterans attended college by 1947, most in black colleges, but almost as many, 15,000, could not gain entry. Predictably, the disproportionately few African Americans who did gain access to their educational benefits were able, like their white counterparts, to become doctors and engineers, and to enter the black middle class. . . .

The record is very clear. Instead of seizing the opportunity to end institutionalized racism, the federal government did its level best to shut and double-seal the postwar window of opportunity to African-Americans’ faces. It consistently refused to combat segregation in the social institutions that were key to upward mobility in education, housing, and employment.

Moreover, federal programs that were themselves designed to assist demobilized GIs and young families systematically discriminated against African Americans. Such programs reinforced white/nonwhite racial distinctions even as intrawhite racialization was falling out of fashion. This other side of the coin, that white men of northwest European ancestry and white men of southeastern European ancestry were treated equally in theory and practice in regard to the benefits they received, was part of the larger postwar whitening of Jews and other eastern and southern Europeans.

To say that Jews pulled themselves up by their own bootstraps ignores the fact that it took federal programs to create the conditions whereby the abilities of Jews and other European immigrants could be recognized and rewarded rather than denigrated and denied. The GI Bill and FHA and VA mortgages, even though they were advertised as open to all, functioned as a set of racial privileges. They were privileges because they were extended to white GIs but not to black GIs. . . .

Jews and other white ethnics’ upward mobility was due to programs that allowed us to float on a rising economic tide. To African Americans, the government offered the cement boots of segregation, redlining, urban renewal, and discrimination.

read "stuff white people do"

children dancing in Scotland,
circa 1900 or so


This blog has reached the 100-post mark, and it's great to see that the anti-racism effort I started here three months ago is steadily gaining a wider audience (the page-view counter at the bottom should reach 50,000 today). The readership here is clearly diverse, and in ways beyond race, as evinced by the lively Comments sections.

And as the sampling below from other blogs indicates, the word about "stuff white people do" is spreading--in a good way.

All of which makes me want to pause for a moment of celebration. In fact, it makes me . . . want to . . . dance! (Stop me when I'm starting to sound too much like Ellen.)

For instructions on how to dance along, see the video at the bottom of this post.

Regular programming of the serious sort will resume momentarily. . .


Changeseeker @ Why Am I Not Surprised:

[L]ast night, thanks to a comment by Professor Zero, I discovered a new blog called Stuff White People Do. The author is smart, right on the target, introspective and clever. He reads all the same books as I do, watches all the same movies, and shares many of the same opinions. And he's written almost as much in the past ninety days as I wrote all last year.

I was tired when I reached SWPD last night and after about an hour on the site, I decided that I'm no longer necessary to the blogosphere, after all . . . Then, I remembered what I had learned the night before (see this post), so I shook off the feeling and just celebrated the blog. . . . if you haven't read Macon D. over at Stuff White People Do yet, then let me send you on over there post haste.

Just recognize that you're probably gonna be there for a while.


Kelsey Atherton @ Plastic Manzikert:

Stuff White People Do: This is fantastic, and part of that is how the blog is still struggling to understand what it is about. I've written about the blog before, and rather recently. I've been reading it for much longer, when I saw it buried in a comment thread at Stuff White People Like. The blog then was rough, and a little glib. Now it's matured into something that is still rough, but does an excellent job of showcasing the uncomfortable discussions of race and privilege. The unspoken last part of the title is "Stuff White People Do (with privilege that enables them to ignore race and to affirm white identity while paying lip service to racial equality)". That's a lot of subtext, and the blog bears it in a properly uncomfortable way. And it does that in a really good way. It's hard to recommend something that sounds so unpleasant, but the experience is worth it, and it isn't as bad as it first seems. It's the learning kind of uncomfortable, not the terror kind.



Shaina Monfils @ The Feminist Writer:

Learning about race and sociology at the University completely changed how I view the world. Obviously, I still participate in the benefits of white privilege, because all white people get those whether they want them or not (which, by the way, is an important thing for all whites to recognize, lest we run around with the attitude of "I'm not racist, so therefore solving racism is about changing those other racist people"). But the thing that really gets under my skin is when people assume that racism is a dormant problem that is either already solved, or an issue that we can't do anything to change. The blog Stuff White People Do looks at the effects of white privilege from the point of view of a white dude named Macon D, in order to help people understand the ways in which they're participating in the continuation of racism. . . .

I also found it interesting that Macon D states that his goal in producing the blog is to write explicitly about whiteness. He says that
I’ve noticed, for instance, that when I ask white individuals to talk about whiteness, about what their being white means for them, they usually have very little to say, and they eventually end up talking about non-white people instead. White Americans are usually unaccustomed to talking directly about their own whiteness, and when asked to do so, they often shift to discussing it in relation to other races, and then end up talking almost exclusively about those other people instead. ("sit quietly in movie theaters - part two")
Personally, I think the reason that the reason white scholars try to stay away from examinations of whiteness is because they don't want to appear to be reducing the discussion to a white viewpoint. As in, "even though minorities have endured centuries of enslavement and abuse, racism is really all about white people in the end." But if white people are racist, and especially if they are unknowingly so, doesn't the solution to the problem lie in getting them to recognize their behavior as racist, and then encouraging them to change it? It seems to me that instead of white people "learning" to "accept" minorities, racism should be dealt with by demonstrating to whites that they are the ones that are flawed, because they buy into the idea that minorities are "different" in the first place.

Blogs such as Stuff White People Do are so instrumental in drawing attention to the blatant privilege present in our society today. It's good to see that readers are getting all riled up in the Comments section of the posts, because it gives me hope that perhaps there are still some individuals out there who are engaged in an ongoing discussion about racism and classism, and are committed to making a change.


Thank you, Changeseeker, Shaina, and Kelsey, and thanks also to others who have mentioned this blog on theirs.

As I said above, all of this is cause for a pause, a celebratory pause. And as regular SWPD readers know, I think white people should dance more often--so here we go.

And for my totally serious readers, there is a lesson here, especially for white parents: "Get them started young!"





To a Child Dancing in the Wind

I

DANCE there upon the shore;
What need have you to care
For wind or water’s roar?
And tumble out your hair
That the salt drops have wet;
Being young you have not known
The fool’s triumph, nor yet
Love lost as soon as won,
Nor the best labourer dead
And all the sheaves to bind.
What need have you to dread
The monstrous crying of wind?

II

Has no one said those daring
Kind eyes should be more learn’d?
Or warned you how despairing
The moths are when they are burned,
I could have warned you, but you are young,
So we speak a different tongue.

O you will take whatever’s offered
And dream that all the world’s a friend,
Suffer as your mother suffered,
Be as broken in the end.
But I am old and you are young,
And I speak a barbarous tongue.


William Butler Yeats (Responsibilities and Other Poems, 1916)

Monday, July 7, 2008

go along with racism instead of calling it what it is



C is a white friend of mine who just moved into a new apartment a couple of months ago. She’s been increasingly upset lately, because she doesn’t enjoy living there yet, and she's not sure why. What’s really been bothering her is not so much the apartment itself nor the area of the city that it’s in. It’s more that, although she likes those things, she’s still not comfortable in her new living situation, and she just hasn't been able to figure out why.

Yesterday, as we talked about her feelings, she realized that the bad feeling about her new place has been coming to her in moments when she talks to her white friends, family members, and co-workers. In particular, this feeling about her new apartment seems to be connected to the common reaction among the white people she knows to the apartment, or rather to its location.

She moved from a rather bohemian, largely white part of her Midwestern American city to a largely non-white area. C says she doesn’t mind the area’s racial makeup, and that she even likes it. The apartment itself was actually the clincher—it’s nicer for the price than the one she’d been renting before. She says that lately, she’s enjoyed exploring the different kinds of people and shops and restaurants in the area, and that being in such a minority as a white person hasn’t caused any problems that she’s aware of.

C has every reason to like the apartment and its location, so we tried to talk through her lingering dissatisfaction with it. The more we talked, the more evident it became that it was the reaction of her friends and acquaintances, almost all of whom are white, that was somehow bothering her. Their feelings about the apartment, and especially about the neighborhood, and especially about the neighborhood's people, were affecting her own feelings about all of that.

What C was feeling, without quite realizing what it was, was a collective white fear of and disdain for the neighborhood and, especially, for the people living there. This common white attitude toward largely non-white neighborhoods was pressuring her in ways that she hadn’t realized were really about race, and racism.

“When I told my [white] friends and the people I work with where I live,” C said, “they all had the same reaction.”

C frowned and curled her lips as she imitated the incredulous disdain her friends, acquaintances, and family members: “’Why would you move to THAT part of town?’ ‘Why would you want to move THERE?’ ‘How will you ever get along with your neighbors?’ And so on.

“But here’s weird thing,” C continued. “I got to thinking about my reaction to what they were all saying. I realized after awhile that my reaction was always the same—I defended the neighborhood. ‘Oh, but it’s not so bad, not so bad at all!’ or ‘It’s really a much more interesting place, with more different things going on, and it has a lot of interesting restaurants and things that I didn’t have in my old neighborhood.'”

“Why is that weird?” I asked. “I mean, I think a lot of people in your situation would defend their new neighborhood. You made a decision to move there, and so you wanted to defend that decision. I don’t think most people would find your reaction weird . . .”

“Right, but the thing was, I knew at some level that their reactions were racist. I realized at some point, after hearing the same basic reaction again and again, and then saying the same things all the time in return, that neither one of us was talking about the real issue, the one they were really talking about—race.”

“Ah. Right. So, can you explain how you see that now as the real issue?”

“Well, it’s obvious now, and it really bothers me how we didn’t come out and just SAY it to each other. I mean, we’re all good, well-meaning people, or we think we are, but we’re really white people who are afraid of black neighborhoods. And Mexican people. We don’t want to be around those people if we don’t know them. And we sure don’t want to LIVE around too many of them. So their reactions to my neighborhood were racist. And instead of calling them on that, instead of pointing it out to them, I went along with this kind of unspoken racism. I played right along with it. Without even realizing I was doing that.”

My friend C’s voice had begun to shake, and then she started crying.

“I don’t know,” she said, shaking her head. “I just don’t know. I mean, it’s like that white privilege stuff that you write about on your blog. It really is there in all of this, somehow, and I played along with it! I’m so MAD that shit is in my head! I let their racism pass, each and every time, and I let the whole conversation be about my defense of the neighborhood, instead of . . .”

C sort of wiggled her hand in the air, then rubbed the fingers of that hand together as she frowned, trying to find the words. Then when she found some words, she clenched her hand into a fist.

“Instead of just calling them out on what they were really saying. On the racism of what they were really saying.”

C wiped away a line of tears on her cheek.

“I felt a pressure from them, a racist pressure. And instead of resisting that, let alone pointing it out, I went along with it. So I was acting racist too, even though I’m the one who moved into that neighborhood! Even though I like it, and I don’t really have that feeling they do about it being scary or whatever because it has so few white people.

“But I think, I still wasn’t liking the neighborhood, because, well you know, it’s a new place, and it is busier and noisier than my other place. But I wanted to tell you about this, because I realize now that I was sort of going along with that white fear of the place too, that my friends were expressing.”

“Expressing without really saying it,” I said.

“Right, because of course, THEY’RE not racists, they would say. Nobody’s a racist anymore, right? At least nobody I know, nobody THEY know. But I was letting how THEY felt about the place affect how I feel about it. Without even realizing that was going on.”

We were quiet for a minute or two.

C then said that she feels better about her new place because she’s no longer letting the feelings of other white people, people whom she otherwise likes and loves, affect her own feelings about the place. But she still feels bad about realizing that those people she loves have such strongly, unreasonably, fearfully racist attitudes. And there was her lingering anger, too, about having such feelings inside herself, feelings that she still has to overcome sometimes in her new surroundings.

I think that seemed to both of us like enough for now. Having figured out a thing or two about whiteness, we went on to talk in more detail about her new apartment, which I hadn’t seen yet, and about her neighbors. She says she’s kind of a loner, “kind of a hermit,” but she is getting to know some new “nice people.”

I don’t think C has her feelings about race in her neighborhood quite worked out yet, but I do think she sees something about herself and her white friends that she hadn’t seen before.

That something is not only a kind of veiled racism, which both she and her friends took part in. It's also the power of whiteness—what it’s done to her and to the white people she knows. How it’s trained them. And how white supremacy subtly coerces goodhearted white people into cooperation and complicity.

Saturday, July 5, 2008

white weekend links


  • "It is Not Easy Being White" (Addison Berkeley @ The Naked Loon)

    Let me just start with the word “white.” Who decided that it was okay to call me that? I prefer “Euro-American” or simply “Amero-American.” But white does not even accurately describe the actual color of my skin. Do you know what is actually white? Toilets, mayonnaise, and snow. People call me white right to my face; day in and day out. What they are really calling me is “snowy mayo toilet-skin.”


  • "Uh-Obama: Racism, White Voters and the Myth of Color-Blindness" (Tim Wise @ LA Progressive)

    The extent to which Obama’s white support has been directly related to his downplaying of race issues simply cannot be overstated, as evidenced by the kinds of things many of these supporters openly admit, possessing no sense of apparent irony or misgiving. So, consider the chant offered by his supporters at a recent rally–and frankly, a chant in which whites appeared to be joining with far greater enthusiasm than folks of color–to the effect that “Race Doesn’t Matter, Race Doesn’t Matter,” a concept so utterly absurd, given the way in which race most certainly still matters to the opportunity structure in this country, that one has to almost wretch at the repeated offering of it.


  • "Christian Lander knows the Stuff White People Like" (Mindy Farabee @ Los Angeles Times)

    "The Stuff is more about class than race," Lander said. Yet it's not even precisely rich whiteness that he singles out for his ire. It's moneyed Caucasian liberals saturated with irony and bedecked in ostentatious authenticity and hard-earned nonchalance. "It is the attitude, it's not about the stuff," Lander clarified . . . . "It's all a contest," he said. "It's a competition that's not about money, because that's crass. Authenticity and happiness are valued more than wealth. Wealth was always taken care of in this group of people." Still, the upper middle class is "completely dominated by white people," he emphasized. "If you're from another race and you like the stuff in the book, chances are you will get accused of acting white. . . "


  • "What the Housing Crisis Can Tell Us about Racism, Sexism and Homelessness" (Clayton Perry @ blogcritics magazine)

    If we choose to view each of these problems and its race dynamics as separate issues, then we are guilty of ignoring the points of origin which connect them all together. According to Max Rameau, an organizer with the Center for Pan-African Development in Miami, Florida, the root problems of gentrification in the 2000s are the same as the root problems of segregation in the 1960s: people of colors’ lack of power and control over land, and white supremacy.


  • "'No Irish Need Apply': A Myth of Victimization" (Richard Jensen @ Journal of Social History)

    The Irish American community harbors a deeply held belief that it was the victim of systematic job discrimination in America, and that the discrimination was done publicly in highly humiliating fashion through signs that announced "Help Wanted: No Irish Need Apply." This "NINA" slogan could have been a metaphor for their troubles—akin to tales that America was a "golden mountain" or had "streets paved with gold." But the Irish insist that the signs really existed and prove the existence of widespread discrimination and prejudice.

    The fact that Irish vividly "remember" NINA signs is a curious historical puzzle. There are no contemporary or retrospective accounts of a specific sign at a specific location. No particular business enterprise is named as a culprit. No historian, archivist, or museum curator has ever located one; no photograph or drawing exists. No other ethnic group complained about being singled out by comparable signs. Only Irish Catholics have reported seeing the sign in America—no Protestant, no Jew, no non-Irish Catholic has reported seeing one. This is especially strange since signs were primarily directed toward these others: the signs said that employment was available here and invited Yankees, French-Canadians, Italians and any other non-Irish to come inside and apply. The business literature, both published and unpublished, never mentions NINA or any policy remotely like it. The newspapers and magazines are silent. The courts are silent. There is no record of an angry youth tossing a brick through the window that held such a sign. Have we not discovered all of the signs of an urban legend?


  • "At TBPAC, Chris Rock's unspeakably funny; second show Thursday" (Eric Deggans @ tampabay.com)

    He's dropping serious knowledge about race, culture and class — leavening the lessons with so many laughs, most fans don't even know they're being schooled. For example, check Rock's dissertation on why black women really hate black men who date white women: "Black women are not attracted to white men," he said. "You see a black woman with an overweight white man, that means her credit is (messed) up." . . . " John McCain is too ... old — didn't he used to own Sidney Poiter?" Rock asked, in one of the rare jokes that can be printed in a family newspaper. "Who's going to be his vice president? A nurse?"



And finally, a video for regular SWPD reader Nquest, who says he "should have been a linguist": an interview with the most famous American linguist that most Americans have never heard of, conducted by Ali G, the most famous British b-boy that most Americans have never heard of (unless they've seen him in his other guise, as Borat).



Thursday, July 3, 2008

most embody american-ness

When, in the course of human events, it becomes necessary for one people to dissolve the political bonds which have connected them with another, and to assume among the powers of the earth, the separate and equal station to which the Laws of Nature and of Nature's God entitle them, a decent respect to the opinions of mankind requires that they should declare the causes which impel them to the separation. . . .

We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty, and the pursuit of Happiness. . . .

The history of the present King of Great Britain is a history of repeated injuries and usurpations, all having in direct object the establishment of an absolute tyranny over these states. To prove this, let facts be submitted to a candid world.

He has refused his assent to laws, the most wholesome and necessary for the public good. . .

He has excited domestic insurrections amongst us, and has endeavored to bring on the inhabitants of our frontiers, the merciless Indian savages, whose known rule of warfare, is undistinguished destruction of all ages, sexes and conditions.

—The United States Declaration of Independence,
adopted on July 4, 1776


Be in enacted by the State and House of Representatives of the United States of America in Congress assembled, That any alien, being a free white person, who shall have resided within the limits and under the jurisdiction of the United States for the term of two years, may be admitted to become a citizen thereof . . .

—An Act to establish an uniform Rule of Naturalization,
ratified on March 26, 1790


Autonomy is freedom and translates into the much championed and revered "individualism" . . . . Eventually individualism fuses with the prototype of Americans as solitary, alienated, and malcontent. What, one wants to ask, are Americans alienate from? What are Americans always so insistently innocent of? Different from? As for absolute power, over whom is this power held, from whom withheld, to whom distributed?

Answers to these questions lie in the potent and ego-reinforcing presence of an Africanist population. This population is convenient in every way, not the least of which is self-definition. This new white male can convince himself that savagery is "out there."



After 1870, Blacks as well as Whites could naturalize, but not others. . . . from 1870 until the last of the prerequisite laws were abolished in 1952, the White-Black dichotomy in American race relations dominated naturalization law. During this period, Whites and Blacks were eligible for citizenship, but others, particularly those from Asia, were not. Indeed, increasing antipathy toward Asians on the West Coast resulted in an explicit disqualification of Chinese persons from naturalization in 1882. . . .

In 1935, Hitler's Germany limited citizenship to members of the Aryan race, making Germany the only country other than the United States with a racial restriction on naturalization. The fact of this bad company was not lost on those administering our naturalization laws. . . .

In 1952, Congress moved towards wholesale reform, overhauling the naturalization statute to read simply that "[t]he right of a person to become a naturalized citizen of the United States shall not be denied or abridged because of race or sex or because such person is married." Thus, in 1952, racial bars on naturalization came to an official end.

—Ian Haney López, White by Law:
The Legal Construction of Race
(1996, 2006)


I see a pattern running through the matrix of white privilege, a pattern of assumptions which were passed on to me as a white person. There was one main piece of cultural turf; it was my own turf, and I was among those who could control the turf. I could measure up to the cultural standards and take advantage of the many options I saw around me to make what the culture would call a success of my life.

My skin color was an asset for any move I was educated to want to make. I could think of myself as “belonging” in major ways, and of making social systems work for me. I could freely disparage, fear, neglect, or be oblivious to anything outside of the dominant cultural forms. Being of the main culture, I could also criticize it fairly freely. My life was reflected back to me frequently enough so that I felt, with regard to my race, if not to my sex, like one of the real people.

--Peggy McIntosh, "White Privilege and Male Privilege:
A Personal Account of Coming to See Correspondences
through Work in Women’s Studies" (1988)


Deep within the word "American" is its association with race. . . . American means white . . .

--Toni Morrison, Playing in the Dark


hit counter code